CraftedStays alternative for owners who won't DIY
Same destination. One of us drives.
CraftedStays is a very good do-it-yourself builder. VacayDirect is for owners who'd rather not do it themselves. Here's the whole comparison — prices, price history, terms, and who should pick which.

The short answer
CraftedStays is a self-serve direct booking website builder for vacation rental operators that syncs live with five property management systems: Hostaway, Guesty, Hospitable, OwnerRez and Hostfully, with an AI, Aria, that writes pages when your team asks it to. VacayDirect is a done-for-you service: the site is built for you, works with any booking system that offers a widget or booking link, and includes weekly local content in the base price. Choose CraftedStays if you or your team want to run the site yourselves on a supported system; choose VacayDirect if you want it handled.
What is CraftedStays, and what does it cost?
CraftedStays is a direct booking website builder for short-term rental operators. It isn't a booking system in its own right: it sits on top of one, and their pricing page names five — Hostaway, Guesty, Hospitable, OwnerRez and Hostfully. Listings, calendars, pricing and reviews flow live from whichever you use. Setup is self-serve: "Connect your PMS, pick a template, and see a live preview built from your own listings", and their home page says "most self-serve launches are live within a week or two."
CraftedStays now has its own AI, Aria. Their home page says it reads "your portfolio, guest reviews, market intelligence, and brand vision in about 15 minutes", produces a strategy report, and that "Aria writes the pages in your voice." Their Aria page describes the editing: "Describe what you want" and "Aria pulls the right properties, writes the copy, generates imagery, and structures for AI search." After launch, Aria "shows your team the gap", and of a new area guide or a seasonal rewrite the home page says "your marketing person does it, not a ticket queue" (read 16 November 2026).
Their published price is $89.99 a month for the first two properties, plus $8 a month for each property after that, up to twenty. A promotional $69.99 a month was showing for the first twelve months, which the page says "renews at $89.99/mo standard after year one". Above twenty properties, pricing is custom. Operators on one of the five partner systems also get monthly credit for the first twelve months: "Hostfully operators receive the largest credit ($35/mo, $420 first-year savings); other PMS partnerships are $25/mo / $300 first-year savings." There's no setup fee, no booking commission on the pricing page, a 14-day trial with no card, and it's month to month: "You can cancel at any time from inside the dashboard, no contracts and no cancellation fees" (read 16 November 2026).
Two things sit outside the base price. The blog is the Marketing Hub add-on at $30 a month, which their page says currently contains one feature, an integrated blog, with "More marketing tools coming soon." And having the site built for you is a one-time onboarding service, in three sizes: White Glove from $2,500 ("Content migration from your existing site, domain and DNS configured, integrations set up, team trained"), a Growth build from $7,500 ("Custom sections, market and collection pages, integrated forms, on-page SEO, and analytics set up for you"), or an Enterprise build from $14,000, scoped per project. Support on the Host Plan is email, with a "reply within one business day"; Slack access and a dedicated success manager are on the custom Institution Plan.
So the year-one arithmetic for an owner of two properties who wants it done for them is $2,500 plus twelve months at the promotional $69.99 plus the $30 hub — about $3,700 — and after launch, deciding which area guides to ask Aria for, checking them and publishing them is still their team's job. VacayDirect Growth is $1,188 for the same twelve months with the content written and published for you.
What the CraftedStays price does not include
The blog and content tools (Marketing Hub, $30/mo), a person on their side writing and publishing new pages for you after launch (Aria writes what your team asks for), having the site built for you (White Glove from $2,500; Growth builds from $7,500; Enterprise from $14,000), support for a booking system outside their five, or — per their terms of service — the site itself after you leave: "Upon termination of the Services… your CraftedStays Site will be taken offline."
Read on craftedstays.co/pricing, craftedstays.co, their Aria page and their terms of service.
| CraftedStays | VacayDirect | |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Self-serve software | Done-for-you service |
| Base price | $89.99/mo for the first 2 properties, then $8 per property | $99/mo Growth, $199/mo Concierge; no setup fee |
| Promotional pricing | $69.99/mo for the first 12 months, then $89.99 | None. The price is the price. |
| Blog and content tools | Marketing Hub add-on, $30/mo. Aria writes pages when you describe what you want; your team decides what to publish | Area guides, guest pages and FAQs published weekly; you can edit or veto any of it |
| Social media posts | Posting to social accounts not listed on craftedstays.co/pricing (read 15 November 2026); Marketing Hub blog posts get "built-in social share buttons" | On Concierge ($199/mo): 12 posts a month to your Instagram and Facebook, written and scheduled for you. Not on Growth |
| Having it set up for you | One-time: White Glove from $2,500, Growth build from $7,500, Enterprise build from $14,000 | We build it from your current site or listing, included |
| Getting to a preview | Self-serve: "see a live preview built from your own listings" | A working preview on a private address, reviewed before launch |
| Booking system | Hostaway, Guesty, Hospitable, OwnerRez or Hostfully — one is required | None required: our own booking engine is built in. Or any system with a booking widget or booking engine link |
| Live rates and availability | Native sync rendered inside the site | From our booking engine, or through your booking system's own widget |
| Checkout | Native PMS or Stripe checkout | Stripe, into your own Stripe account, or your booking system's checkout; money goes straight to you |
| Booking commission | None on the pricing page (but see the terms note below) | None |
| Structured for AI answers | Yes — "headed sections, FAQ blocks, review markup" | Vacation rental structured data on every page |
| Guest assistant | Not listed on the Host Plan | 24/7 guest assistant that answers questions and captures inquiries |
| Making changes | Your team, in plain language with Aria: "your marketing person does it, not a ticket queue" | Chat with the site's AI agent (preview before publishing); on Concierge a person, typically 1–2 business days |
| Support | Email, reply within one business day; Slack and a dedicated CSM on Institution | Concierge plan: a named contact and a person handling unlimited requests |
| Property limit | Up to 20 on the Host Plan; custom above that | No limit on the number of properties |
| Contract | Month to month, no cancellation fees | Month to month; cancel any time |
| If you cancel | "Your CraftedStays Site will be taken offline" | We transfer the website and its hosting to you. On our booking engine you also get a full export of your booking data, and your payment history stays in your own Stripe account |
| Trial | 14 days, no card | No free trial; month to month from launch |
CraftedStays details are quoted from craftedstays.co/pricing, its home page and craftedstays.co/terms-of-service, read 16 November 2026. Check their site for current pricing.
| Archived copy of their pricing page | Standard price shown | Price shown to new customers | Add-ons on the page |
|---|---|---|---|
| December 2024 | $89.99/mo (2 properties) | $59.99/mo | None priced |
| May 2025 | $89.99/mo | $59.99/mo | None priced |
| September 2025 | $89.99/mo | $69.99/mo | White Glove listed as an Institution Plan feature |
| January 2026 | $89.99/mo | $69.99/mo | As September 2025 |
| May 2026 | $89.99/mo | $69.99/mo, "first 12 months", renews at $89.99 | Marketing Hub, $30/mo, appears |
| September 2026 (their live page) | $89.99/mo | $69.99/mo, first 12 months | Marketing Hub $30/mo; White Glove from $1,500; custom build from $4,500 |
| November 2026 (their live page) | $89.99/mo | $69.99/mo, first 12 months | Marketing Hub $30/mo; White Glove from $2,500; Growth build from $7,500; Enterprise build from $14,000 |
Archived copies of craftedstays.co/pricing on web.archive.org, read 22 September 2026, and their live page, read 22 September and 16 November 2026. The $89.99 standard price hasn't moved; the discount shown to new customers has narrowed from $30 to $20, and is now explicitly limited to the first year. Between September and November 2026, White Glove onboarding rose from $1,500 to $2,500, and the custom build from $4,500 gave way to Growth (from $7,500) and Enterprise (from $14,000) builds.
| CraftedStays, self-serve | CraftedStays, done for you | VacayDirect Growth | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year one | $839.88 (12 × $69.99) | $3,699.88 ($2,500 + 12 × $69.99 + 12 × $30 hub) | $1,188 |
| Years two and three | $2,159.76 (24 × $89.99) | $2,879.76 (24 × $89.99 + 24 × $30) | $2,376 |
| Three-year total | $2,999.64 | $6,579.64 | $3,564 |
| Who builds it | You | Them (White Glove) | Us |
| Who publishes new content | You or your team, with Aria writing what you ask for (no blog without the $30 hub) | Your team, with Aria | Us, every week |
Our arithmetic on CraftedStays' published prices, read 16 November 2026, assuming the first-year promotional rate is still available when you sign up and no extra properties. It leaves out their PMS partner credits ($25 or $35 a month for the first year), because their page doesn't say whether those combine with the promotional rate; with them, the CraftedStays columns would be $300 to $420 lower. It excludes booking software: CraftedStays needs one of its five, while VacayDirect works with yours or without one, using our own booking engine.
You do / we do
You do, we do: getting found on CraftedStays
Getting found on Google and in AI answers is work: pages to build, local pages to write, search terms to chase, a site to keep current. Here is the work CraftedStays' pages describe as yours, quoted from their own pages, and who does each task on VacayDirect. We promise the work, not the results.
Set up the site
- On CraftedStays, you do it
"Connect your PMS, pick a template, and see a live preview built from your own listings."
Read on craftedstays.co/pricing, 16 November 2026.
- On VacayDirect
- We build the site from your current website or listing. You review a working preview on a private address and tell us what to change. No booking software is required: our own booking engine is built in.
Point your domain at the site
- On CraftedStays, you do it
"We hand off DNS instructions, you flip your domain when ready."
Read on craftedstays.co/pricing, 16 November 2026.
- On VacayDirect
- We walk you through the one DNS update, set up redirects from your old URLs and submit the sitemap.
Act on the AI-search gaps
- On CraftedStays, you do it
Their AI, Aria, "audits your pages against the structure AI needs, then shows your team the gap."
Read on craftedstays.co, 16 November 2026.
- On VacayDirect
- Every month we check what ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google's AI say when a traveler asks where to stay near you, and what they say about your place by name. Every month we work out the searches and AI questions worth winning near your place, and match each one to a page on your site.
Write new area guides and seasonal pages
- On CraftedStays, you do it
"A new area guide, a page for the guests you book most, a rewrite for the season: your marketing person does it, not a ticket queue."
Read on craftedstays.co, 16 November 2026.
- On VacayDirect
- We publish area guides and guest-type pages every week, on both plans, written from the facts about your place. You can edit or veto any of them. On Growth, tell your site's AI agent and approve a preview. On Concierge, unlimited change requests are handled by a person.
What they do for you: CraftedStays' AI, Aria, writes the pages from your portfolio and guest reviews, and its White Glove onboarding (from $2,500, one-time) migrates content, configures DNS and sets up integrations for you; its Growth builds (from $7,500) add custom sections, market pages and on-page SEO, and Enterprise builds (from $14,000) a bespoke design. Its blog is the Marketing Hub add-on at $30 a month.
Who it suits better: If you like being hands-on, or have a marketing person who'll make the changes, CraftedStays is built for that, and its native sync with five booking systems goes deeper than a widget.
Where CraftedStays sits in the market
There are three ways to get a direct booking site: build one yourself on a dedicated builder, use the website tool inside your booking software, or have one built and run for you. CraftedStays is the best-known example of the first kind — a builder that does nothing but rental websites, on top of your property management software rather than instead of it. OwnerRez even documents the CraftedStays integration in its own help center.
That positioning is the whole comparison in miniature. CraftedStays gives a hands-on operator a better website than their PMS's built-in tool. We give an owner who won't be hands-on a website at all.
Where CraftedStays is the better choice
If you manage a larger portfolio on one of their five supported systems and you want property search, rates and availability rendered natively inside the site, their sync is deeper than a widget. If you like being hands-on with your site, or you have a marketing person, their AI editor is built for that: Aria writes pages in your voice when your team describes what it wants, and a self-serve preview built from your own listings is a real advantage over waiting for anybody, including us.
They have also published genuinely useful original research on how AI assistants choose which rental sites to cite — a study of thousands of guest questions across several engines and markets. It is theirs, and it's worth reading. We're not going to restate their findings as if we'd done the work.
Where VacayDirect is the better choice
If your honest answer to "when will you build the site?" is "never", you need a service, not software. Even a builder whose AI writes on request still needs someone to decide what to ask for, check it and publish it.
We build it, we migrate it and we keep publishing the area guides and guest pages that owners intend to write and don't. If you're on a booking system outside the big five — a smaller regional PMS, a channel manager nobody has integrated with, or a plain booking link — we can still work with it, because we embed your booking widget rather than syncing to your database. And if you have no booking system at all, our own booking engine is built in.
What happens if you leave
This is the difference most comparison pages skip, and it matters more than any feature. CraftedStays' terms of service say that on termination "your CraftedStays Site will be taken offline." That's normal for hosted software — you're renting the platform — but it means leaving CraftedStays means rebuilding somewhere else.
Our FAQ says the opposite: your site lives in its own code repository, and if you cancel, we transfer the site and its hosting to you. The domain was always yours, because you pay for it directly.
One clause worth asking them about
CraftedStays' pricing page says "no booking commission" and "no markup on guest payments". Their terms of service also define "Transaction Fees" as "fees relating to the value of sales or bookings made through your Site when using all payment providers other than CraftedStays Payments." The terms read as though they were adapted from a general e-commerce template — they mention point-of-sale services and Ontario law — so the pricing page may well be the operative promise. But it's a two-line email to confirm before you sign, and we'd send it.
The part we agree on
CraftedStays' own research concluded that what separates operators who get cited by AI assistants from ones who don't is a deep library of local, guest-focused pages — area guides and guest-type pages, not backlinks. We think that's right, and it's why content is in our base price rather than a $30 add-on.
The difference is who does the work. On CraftedStays, Aria finds the gaps and writes the pages your team asks for, in your voice. Someone on your side still decides which forty pages to ask for — the lake, the ski bus, the best breakfast within walking distance, which bedroom the kids should take — checks what comes back against what they know, and publishes it. That's the work owners reliably don't get to, and on VacayDirect it's ours, every week, on both plans.
Moving from CraftedStays to VacayDirect
Your booking system doesn't move at any point, so neither do your reservations.
Keep CraftedStays running
Don't cancel anything yet. The old site keeps taking bookings while we build the new one.
We rebuild from your live site
Pages, photos and copy come across from what's published now. You review a working preview on a private address.
We embed your booking system's widget
The same PMS that feeds CraftedStays feeds the new site, through its own booking widget. Guest payments keep going to your account.
Switch the domain, redirect every URL
Your domain points to the new site and every old page URL redirects to its new home, so nothing you've earned in search is dropped.
Then cancel CraftedStays
Once bookings are flowing on the new site. Their terms say the old site goes offline on termination, which by then is what you want.
Questions
What owners ask us
What does CraftedStays cost?
Their pricing page lists $89.99 a month for the first two properties and $8 a month per property after that, up to twenty, with a promotional $69.99 for the first twelve months that renews at the standard rate. The Marketing Hub add-on, which carries the blog, is $30 a month. Done-for-you onboarding is extra and one-time: White Glove from $2,500, Growth builds from $7,500, Enterprise builds from $14,000. No setup fee on the software itself, and month to month (read 16 November 2026).
Has CraftedStays raised its prices?
Not the standard price: archived copies of their pricing page show $89.99 for two properties from December 2024 to today. What changed is the discount — new customers saw $59.99 through May 2025 and $69.99 from September 2025 — and by May 2026 the discount was explicitly limited to the first twelve months. The $30 Marketing Hub add-on first appears in May 2026. The onboarding services have gone up: White Glove was listed from $1,500 in September 2026 and from $2,500 in November 2026, when the custom build from $4,500 had given way to Growth builds from $7,500 and Enterprise builds from $14,000.
Is VacayDirect cheaper than CraftedStays?
Self-serve, no: CraftedStays is cheaper if you'll build and write it yourself — about $3,000 over three years for two properties against $3,564 for VacayDirect Growth. Done for you, yes: with White Glove onboarding (from $2,500) and the Marketing Hub, CraftedStays comes to about $6,580 over the same three years on their published prices, and after launch your team would still decide, check and publish the new pages Aria writes.
Do I need a property management system to use CraftedStays?
Yes. CraftedStays sits on top of a PMS and their site lists five: Hostaway, Guesty, Hospitable, OwnerRez and Hostfully. If you're not on one of those, it isn't for you. VacayDirect embeds whatever booking widget or booking link you already have, including a plain booking link if that's genuinely all you have.
What happens to my CraftedStays site if I cancel?
Their terms of service say that on termination "your CraftedStays Site will be taken offline", and "CraftedStays does not provide refunds." That's standard for hosted software. With VacayDirect the site lives in its own code repository and we transfer the site and its hosting to you if you cancel.
Does CraftedStays charge commission on bookings?
Their pricing page says no — "no setup fee, no booking commission, and no markup on guest payments." Their terms of service separately define "Transaction Fees" on bookings made through payment providers other than CraftedStays Payments. The pricing page is the clearer statement, but it's worth asking them to confirm in writing which applies to you.
What support does CraftedStays offer?
On the Host Plan, email support with a reply within one business day, per their pricing page. The custom Institution Plan adds a Slack channel with a faster response time and a dedicated customer success manager. VacayDirect Concierge includes a named contact and unlimited change requests handled by a person, typically within one to two business days.
Which is better for AI search?
Both build sites with structured data, and structured data is table stakes. CraftedStays' own published research found that the operators who get cited have a deep library of local, guest-focused pages. VacayDirect writes and publishes that library for you every week. On CraftedStays, Aria finds the gaps and writes pages when your team asks; deciding what to ask for, checking it and publishing it stays with your team.
What are the best CraftedStays alternatives?
It depends what you were buying it for. For the same self-serve model, the website builders inside Lodgify, OwnerRez, Hostaway, Guesty or Hospitable cover similar ground and you may already pay for one; Boostly Connect is a free WordPress plugin for up to ten listings if you already run WordPress. For the done-for-you outcome White Glove buys, the alternatives are Boostly's service, a freelance designer, or a managed subscription like ours.
Can I move from CraftedStays to VacayDirect?
Yes. We rebuild from your live site, keep your URLs where we can and put redirects in place for anything that changes. Your booking system doesn't move — it stays exactly where it is and we embed it.
Will I lose the live availability calendar?
No, but it's delivered differently. CraftedStays reads your PMS directly and renders search and availability natively. We embed your booking system's own widget, which reads from the same calendar. Guests see live rates and availability either way; the native version can be styled more deeply into the page.
Let's get your place its own front door.
A 30-minute call. We'll look at your current site or listing, tell you what we'd build and answer anything. No pitch deck.